I'll do this differently: I'm going to list some carts that did NOT make the top 5 too (ALL are p-mounts):
Grado black with a 8mz stylus
Digitrac 380 NE
ADC PSX-40
Shure M110HE
Shure/Realistic RXT6
Shure M104e with LP Gear VL stylus.
Shure/Realistic RXT5 with a N97xe stylus.
Audio Technica "AT-92ML" (It's the AT 92e with the ML stylus).
Audio Technica 142LP with a AT152LP stylus.
Audio Technica 8008 (w/ original Shibata stylus)
Technics P33s with SAS stylus.
That said....
5- ADC first gen. p-mount (I have no idea what the model is, but it's the one with the channels reversed).
4 - Empire 395LT with a 246-DEX stylus.
3 - Shure M92 cart with a Radio Shack/Shure RXT5 stylus.
2 - Empire 897 XLT (w/ original 'quad' stylus).
1 - Audio Technica SS330E/U with a AT 212-DE stylus.
Yea, I don't believe it either, but I'm not into specs, name, cost or any of that. The only thing I want is pure sound after I transfer and clean an album, or occasional listening.