• The move to the new server is done. There are some software and database maintenance updates in process. This has us passing the hat around to help out. We appreciate any donations. Seriously, even a dollar helps. The payment page may be found here - https://www.audiokarma.org/support.html

A Cartridge that Sounds Like $1MM for under $200

whell

AK Subscriber
Subscriber
So, how do you put together a cartridge that, in this writer's opinion, can compete with the best moving magnet cartridges available today for under $200? Its not that hard, really. And, if you get a little luck on your side, you might be able to put this together for far less than $200.

At the heart of the matter is the Stanton 890 SA DJ cartridge. That's right, its a DJ cartridge. Kevin at KAB sells this cartridge with a Pickering D22E stylus, and it's supposed to sound very good. Why a DJ cartridge? Well, this particular DJ cartridge started its life many years ago as a Stanton 881. The 881 was one of the best moving magnet cartridges of its era, and holds up well against the competition today. The 890 SA, therefore, can use the same styli that are available for the 881.

Note, the 890 SA is usually sold in pairs. However, you can find single units available for under $80, such as is shown here:

http://www.topdjgear.com/stanton-890-sa.html

However, if you get lucky, you might find a DJ retiring some of his/her gear, like I did, and pick up the 890 used for a cheap. The stock stylus is a conical, which really doesn't sound too bad. A bit brassy in the highs for my tastes, but it could last someone a while until the funds become available for the second part of this equation - the stylus upgrade.

To me, one of the best available options is the Shibata stylus available from the likes of Jico, LP Gear and others. LP Gear also makes a hyper-elliptical stylus which is supposed to sound very nice as well. You can also pick up the Pickering stylus from KABUSA, though he's got less than 100 of these on hand.

Prices for styli?

JICO Shibata: $87.00

LP Gear Shibata: $99.95

LP Gear Pickering D3000 Stylus (Shibata): $86.95

LP Gear Hyper-Elliptical: $49.95

So, you can get into the cartridge for $79.95 or less, and the stylus for $99.95 or less. For that price, you get a cartridge that, I think, competes with the best there is in the moving magnet realm, and many in the moving coil realm, for a fraction of what many of those best of breed cartridges are going for today.
 
Register to hide this ad
Well, in that case, I just might have to go with the Koetsu! :)

However, those who's budgets don't accommodate a Koetsu, you can still check out the Stanton.
 
I can't attest to all of them. I've got the Jico Shibata for the 881S and I love it. I've heard very good things about the hyper-elliptical, but I've not personally heard it. For the $$$, I can't imagine that you'd be disappointed.
 
Thank you for the recommendation. I bought a Stanton D5200 SK when I first got into vinyl as that was the only cartridge I could find for sale locally. I always thought it had pretty decent sound overall for a dj cartridge.

I have another stanton cartridge that came with a D75S stylus and brush. The stylus got damaged in shipping. I wonder if this is cartridge is close to the 890/881? There aren't any markings on the body to identify which one it is.
 
The D75S is an excellent stylus for the 68X series of cartridges. LP Gear, among others, carries replacements. They have both a Shibata and a Hyper-elliptical at different price points.
 
Nice thread Mike...thanks to folks like yourself people are beginning to realize the sonic capabilities of these Stanton/Pickering cartridges...They truly represent one of the better values/bang for buck components in the audio chain...
I look at cartridges as my tone control....just like tube rolling
 
+1 On a great thread Mike! This is a wonderful way for a lot of folks to experience an Enourmous leap in sound quality for a small price! I have always beleved in the fact that other than speakers, your cart is the single largest improvement in sound you can do. Thanks for a great thread.
 
Thanks Mike for the post. It's very informative.

I have a stanton cs100. It sounds really good! I believe the stylus is compatible with 881. Anyway, did you hear any significant difference between elliptical and shibata? I need to look for a replacement stylus.

By the way, I've compared Micro Benz Gold, Stanton CS100, and Denon DL110 on my Well Tempered. Denon sounds pretty good at way under $200.

Thanks
 
I look at cartridges as my tone control....just like tube rolling

Quoted for truth. Very well put, and I completely agree! "Cartridge rolling" is a fun and educational experience! :music:



Mike, thanks for sharing this! It's not like I need another project on my "Have to try this!" list, but this one sounds very promising. Love any projects that bring huge value-for-money returns, and give us high-end sound on hamburger budgets! :yes: :thmbsp:

Maybe one day we'll put them all together, the things like this and Petra cables, and come up with a complete ultra-value DIY turntable package! :D
 
I can't attest to all of them. I've got the Jico Shibata for the 881S and I love it. I've heard very good things about the hyper-elliptical, but I've not personally heard it. For the $$$, I can't imagine that you'd be disappointed.

Thank you for making this cartridge option known...

What tracking force are you using?

Does changing the stylus from the stock conical to an HE or Shibata affect the manufacturer's recommended tracking force?
 
I have a stanton cs100. It sounds really good! I believe the stylus is compatible with 881. Anyway, did you hear any significant difference between elliptical and shibata? I need to look for a replacement stylus.

Thanks

The CS 1000 used the WOS 100 stylus, if memory serves. I think the 881 stylus would be compatible. Its a bummer that the original stylus is no longer available, and I'm not aware of any quality aftermarket replacement.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for making this cartridge option known...

What tracking force are you using?

Does changing the stylus from the stock conical to an HE or Shibata affect the manufacturer's recommended tracking force?

The conical tracks better at 2 - 3 grams. The HE and Shibata will track nicely in the 1 - 1.5 range.
 
Dang, the more I listen to this combo, the better it sounds. I've used the 980 with both an OEM D22S stylus, and with the Jico Shibata replacement for the D81S stylus. Both stylus' have their own somewhat unique sound, but both sound absolutely terrific with the 980. Lotsa bang for the buck here, I think!
 
Will this combo work for the SL1200 MKii? Just a quick question as I really have no idea how to check this out.
 
Absolutely. I use this combo on my SL-1210 M5G, which has pretty much the same tonearm as the MK II.
 
hmm...this sounds very interesting then. I will have to see if I can source these up here. I assume this would be a "large" improvement over my Ortofon 2m
 
Back
Top Bottom