I agree with your post about cleanning old records and the fact that some are just to far gone to bother with...as for the best way to clean them I have seen and tried alot of the different cleaning solutions (store bought and DIY) and methods (different cloths, brushes, etc...) but if you can afford one (the prices have come down some) or have the savy to build your own, purchase or build a record cleaning machine (one that uses a vacume)...this is the best way to clean up and old vinyl record..after I purchased one some of the old vinyl records that I have "cleaned" using differnt solutions, rags, brushes just came to life after I cleaned it on my record cleaning machine......this is the best way to go........granted there are still agruments about different cleaning solutions, bushes to use during the cleaning process, etc....but the best way to get all the dirt, left over cleaning solution, etc....off the surface of the record is to use a vacume device.......period.
It is pretty easy to do a test comparison, this is how I did it.....I took a vinyl disk that I had cleaned (or thought I had cleaned) up to a local stereo shop that cleaned records for a fee using a record cleaning machine....I had the disc cleaned, brought it home and was amazed at the difference.....I was sold, went out and ordered one.....was the best investment that I ever made. Hope this helps.............:thmbsp: