Wow, this radio studio thing seems to have derailed this thread completely. Since there has been so much interest and passionate discussion I wonder if we should not start a new thread dedicated to radio studios in the General Audio Discussions section, what do you think? For the time being, here are a few replies to the posts directed to me.
There is no such thing as "ordinairy layout of control rooms in European mainstream radios"
God knows that I hate to contradict people, but
of course there is such a thing - and the photos you posted illustrate it nicely too. U-shaped layout with the mixing desk at one end, turntables on one side, tape decks on the other side... sounds familiar? Then there are just two variants:
- Self-op ("DJ-style") with a microphone at the mixing desk so that the presenter/producer is also the tech.
- Tech-op where the tech/s at the mixing desk is in charge of cueing and launching the recorded sounds and all the technicalities in the control room, while the presenter in the studio room - on the other side of the sound-proof window - does the talking and is usually also the director and producer, both being in communication by means of talkback and a specific sign language nicknamed "technical gestures".
I appreciate that Self-op is the only style that you know, but you have to be aware that Tech-op is very common in European radios, including community and commercial radios. Radio France is a "Tech-op only" radio - and very proud of the high level of creativity and technicity that this allows, while other European broadcasters (BBC, etc.) have a mix of both styles: mostly tech-op in nationwide stations, mostly self-op in local stations where the budget is tighter. Your photos show both styles, almost always with this same basic layout. I have been informed that the new (2021) RTBF studios in Mons are designed to allow both modes of operation too - but of course it's easier with the modern technologies.
Since you showed a photo of a local BBC station, check page 93 in the BBC guide to Acoustic Practice (
http://downloads.bbc.co.uk/rd/pubs/...tural-acoustics/bbc_guideacousticpractice.pdf) which shows a better view of the whole floorplan. It shows how these BBC local studios can be used in both ways, with the on-desk microphones and thoughtully placed turntables for self-operation, but also a row of tape recorders and a separate studio room for tech-operation. As you can see by comparing both shots, all these studios have the same general organisation, dictated by ergonomics and experience.
Of course, as all rules, this one has a few exceptions, such as your photo with a turntable on the left hand and another on the right hand - great for juggling with LP's but too awkward if you add tape recorders, as they would be too far away from the mixing desk for one-person operation, and cueing tapes would be too noisy in the same room as the microphone. This studio is basically limited to DJ programmes, which is probably the whole point. Another oddball case is outside broacasting where you have to do with whatever room and furniture the organisers allow you to use - as in the example there:
http://www.stanlaundon.com/tees.html (look up "outside broadcast" photos). For more information on how radio studios are organised, I encourage you to read this page:
https://www.cloudrad.io/radio-studio.
(as you can see NOB probably had a contract with EMT
)
EMT was indeed a major player in Europe for the mainstream (or "big" if you prefer) radios that had the budget to afford them. I don't know everything, but I am not aware of a "contract" between any manufacturer and any broadcasting company, if by this you mean a guaranteed stream of orders on the long-term.
a time that the state controlled 100% of the radio&television broadcasting and that commercial stations were forbidden.
Ahem... Look up "Europe 1", "RTL (French radio)", "RMC", "Sud Radio", "Radio Andorre" and "Radio Océan / Atlantic 2000" on the wikipedia for actual information on what you're talking about.
And that it wouldn't be suitable for how popular radio is made where the DJ plays a central role.
Ahem... Just for your information, since a good many years the most popular radio in France has been France Inter, a public radio made in 100% tech-op studios. That's right, no DJ, but a presenter and a producer (who are often the same person). The separation of the roles in Tech-op studios allows the production of much more richer contents than self-op. For instance, the final sequence of Nicolas Philibert's "La maison de la radio" mentioned by LF240 shows the live broadcasting of a
musique concrète concert, something that cannot possibly be done in a self-op studio. I strongly encourage you to find and watch this wonderful - and very funny for the most part - documentary.
The pictures I posted have, therefore, a completely different layout, and show that there isn't something like a "ordinary layout of the control rooms in European mainstream radios".
They all differ, certainly through the ages.
Obviously not, they are operationally all the same - with a single exception - and this, for good reasons. But I do agree that the buttons and the walls are different.[/QUOTE]